Welcome to LinuxCNC.org

jd896 wrote:
Couple of things to consider, cutting speeds and rapid speeds. At cutting speeds you want a tight axis with little following error, at rapid speeds you can have a bit more following error as your not making a part but just getting there. You don't want an overshoot on a deceleration from a rapid or you might ram into a part. So you have to sort out what is acceptable to you for your machine. A plasma might sacrifice some accuracy for acceleration to maintain cutting speeds for artsy fartsy stuff with lots of direction changes.

So run the speeds your interested in obtaining and tune to that.

John

PCW wrote:
could you give this in more detail if possible is there a way to scale the out put also the dacs and scal are limited to 8 as this is the drives max input voltage

thanks pcw i thought it was just me doing something wrong not being able to get much p or ff1

jd896 wrote:
P is right when it is right, there is no absolute numerical target.

I have controller between millibar of oil pressure and valve duty cycle, that has a _tiny_ P term, about 0.002

FF2 will tune out a spike during acceleration
also FF1 will tune out the constant negative following error during cruise

but something is funny here (like a lot of friction or way too low gain)

Notice that during the acceleration phase, the encoder doesn't even register any motion until
acceleration is almost done (end of the commanded velocity ramp-up).

Is this a velocity mode drive?

And like Andy says P is right when its right

Getting the input and output PID scaling right just makes the
numbers look more "normal" it will not affect the performance

thanks PCW ive got the following error down within the 0.0x range now and considering this is mm not inches that not quite good for a plasma at 8ish m/m

also the drive for my y axis came back earlier on today so ive been getting that tuned got down to 0.2 till the morning

would this suffice for a torch control / start plasma routine


o<startcut> sub
M64 P0 (turn on cap height control - D out 1)
G4 P3.1 (pause for height control)
M64 P2 (start plasma - D out 3)
M66 P5 L0 (wait for plasma arc ok - D in 1)
o<startcut> endsub
m2

also the one for end of cut

o<endcut>
M65 P0 (turn cap height off - D out 1)
M64 P1 (raise torch to clearance - D out 2)
G4 P3 (pause for torch movement)
M65 P1 (stop torch up movement)
o<endcut>
m2

also are the M2 commands needed in the o word files ? i presume there to end the o word and continue with the program